Papamuri
mēnā ko taua mate, ko taua kino rānei i puta mai i tētahi huihuinga me te wā whakahoki iti rawa o te 20 tau mō te wāhi kua inihuatia i runga i ngā tatauranga 24 hāora i whakaritea e te Tari Āhuarangi mō te teihana tata ki te wāhi kua inihuatia, mō tētahi atu teihana huarere motuhake rānei e tata ana, e tata ana rānei ki te wāhi kua inihuatia.
He aha te āhua o te papa hangahanga kua inihuatia?
I roto i te kaupapa here ngā whakamāramatanga mō te "Wāhi Kaupapa". I hipokina e tētahi o ēnei whakamāramatanga ngā wāhi kei te mahi te Kaiinihua i ngā mahi, kei te rongoatia, kei te tukatukahia rānei ngā taonga me ngā wāhi katoa e karapoti ana e pā ana ki te Kaupapa . I roto i te Rārangi Kaupapa tētahi atu whakamāramatanga, ā, i whakaurua ngā mahi e uru ana ki te Hoahoa me te Hanga o te whakapai ake i te huarahi tere o nāianei ki tētahi ara waka e whā ngā ara . I whakaurua hoki e te Rārangi Kaupapa ngā piriti hou i runga i ētahi wāhanga o te whitiki me ngā piriti me ngā awaawa waipuke. Ko ngā whakamāramatanga o ētahi atu kupu, pērā i te "Kaupapa", i waiho e te kaupapa here kia tautuhia i roto i ngā kirimana rerekē i waenga i ngā rōpū.
He utu mō ngā mahi pakaru ahakoa ua, ahakoa paki?
I te marama o Hune 2016, ka pā te ua nui ki te raki o New South Wales, ā, ka puta he maha ngā waipuke. He nui te kino o ngā mahi, ā, i tukuna he kereme e Acciona i raro i te kaupapa here.
I tino uaua te whiwhi hipoki nā te mea nā te ua i puta ai te kino. Heoi, nā te kaha o te ua, tera pea i taea te uru ki raro i te whakawāteatanga mō te ua nui whakaharahara. I tuhia e te teihana huarere i te taha o te wāhanga mahi te taumata hei mea kotahi i roto i te 20 tau, koinei tonu te āhua ka whakawāteatia i raro i te kaupapa here.
Ko te uauatanga mō Acciona ko te roa o te huarahi e rua atu ana teihana huarere, ā, he rerekē te nui o te ua i roto i ia teihana e toru. I taua wā, i pātaihia mēnā i puta mai ia puranga kino i te nui o te ua i ringihia i ia wā, i te nui rawa rānei.
Hei whakatū i te whai mana o te rarangi whakakore, me whakatū e te Kōti ko tēhea wāhanga o te papa kaupapa i hipokina e te whakakorenga huarere kino. Ko te mea nui o tēnei whakataunga ko te pānui i te kupu " wāhi inihua" . I kotahi te wāhi o te whitiki katoa? I te wāhi motuhake rānei i pāngia e te kino? I whakapono a Acciona mēnā ka pā te whakakorenga ki tētahi wāhanga o te papa kaupapa, ka hipokina ngā kino katoa, ahakoa tōna tata ki te ua kua hipokina. I tautohe a Zurich ko te wāhi anake i heke ai te ua nui.
Whakataunga Katoa a te Kōti ā-Motu: e mōhio ana te Kōti i ua, engari i ua nui?
Ko te whakatinana i tētahi kaupapa here inihua motuhake ki te mākete i roto i tētahi huarahi mārama, ōrite hoki, me whai whakamaoritanga pakihi kia puta ai he hua arumoni i runga i te māramatanga o tētahi tangata pakihi whai whakaaro ki te tikanga o te kaupapa here.I te aromatawai i te tikanga o te kupu wāhi kua inihuahia i kōrerotia, i whai te Kōti i te huarahi e aro ana ki te arorau me te whai huatanga o te pakihi. I tirohia e te Kōti ngā mea e tika ana i roto i te horopaki o te kaupapa here, ā, i whakapono he uaua ki te kite i te arorau i roto i te aromatawai i te kaha o tētahi huihuinga i tētahi rohe mā te tohutoro ki taua huihuinga anō i tētahi atu. Engari, mā te arorau e kī ko te taumata o te ua me aromatawai e ngā teihana huarere e tata ana ki te kino, kaua i tētahi atu wāhi. He huarahi i ngana ki te mārama ki te kupu mā te whakamahi i te whai huatanga o te pakihi i kitea he hua ōrite. Kāore i taea te whakaputa te whai huatanga pakihi mehemea i pānuitia te kaupapa here i roto i tētahi huarahi e huna ana i te āhua o te kaupapa i puta ai te kino. I tēnei take, ka kitea ngāwari ko tētahi wāhanga noa iho o te kino i te taha o te papa kaupapa i puta mai i tētahi kaupapa i hipokina e te whakakorenga ki te rarangi whakakore. Me pēhea rā te whai tikanga ki te kī ka taea tēnei kaupapa te pā ki ngā wāhi katoa i pakaru? I te kitenga he koretake te pānui a Acciona i te rarangi whakakore, ka whakatau te Kōti he pai ki a Zurich.
Whakamutunga
I te arotahi ki te whai huatanga me te arorau o te pakihi, kua āwhina te Kōti ki te whakatinana i tētahi māramatanga noa mō ngā kupu o te kaupapa here. Mā te mahi pera ka puta he tauira hou o ngā kōti ā-motu i Ahitereiria e whakamahi ana i tētahi huarahi mahi ki te whakamārama i ngā take inihua. [3] Ināianei te āhua nei kua whakamāramahia ngā whakaaetanga i roto i ngā huarahi e whakanui ana i te horopaki pakihi e whakahaerehia ana e rātou. Ko te hua pea kāore e taea te pānui i ngā rarangi whakakore i roto i ngā huarahi pōhēhē. Nā te mea, i ngā wāhi ka taea e te reo te whakapoauau, ka puta te whakaaro noa.
Ngā Tohutoro
[1] Acciona Infrastructure Australia Pty Ltd v Zurich Australian Insurance Limited [2023] FCAFC 47.
[2] Ko te peka o te Liberty Mutual Insurance Company o Ahitereiria e hokohoko ana ko Liberty Specialty Markets v Icon Co (NSW) Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 126 i [152].
[3] Star Entertainment Group Limited v Chubb Insurance Australia Ltd [2021] FCA 907; Outback Music Festival Group Pty Ltd (i mua ko Big Run Events Pty Ltd) v Everest Syndicate 2786 i Lloyd’s [2022] FCA 13.
