I roto i tana tuhinga whakaaro ( NZ Herald 21 Hui-tanguru 2024) e whakarato ana a Mayor Brown i ētahi take mō ēnei tāpaetanga. Kei roto i ēnei ko te aro nui ki ngā pūkenga whakahaere kaua ki ngā pūkenga maha e whai hua tika ana ki te rāngai e whai wāhi ana, te kore aro ki te uara mō te moni kia taea ai te whakatārewa, te whakaiti rānei i te kaupapa mēnā e tika ana kia rite ki tēnā, ā, ka nui haere te whānuitanga nā te mea ko te hunga kāore e utu ana e hiahia ana ki te nui atu i te mea i hiahiatia i te tīmatanga.
E homai ana e ia ngā tauira whakamataku o tēnei taikaha rawa.
E tino whakaae ana mātou, ā, e whakapono ana hoki mātou he take whai take hei tautoko i te tirohanga a te Koromatua o Brown.
He rite tonu tana riri ki tā Simon Wilson ( NZ Herald 1 Hakihea 2023) i tana kīnga me whakahou katoa te hanganga o ā tātou hanganga. E whakaatu ana ia ko ngā utu hanga tereina metro te mea tino nui rawa atu o te ao. E kī ana a Mr Sweeney (te Tumu Whakahaere Matua o tā mātou City Rail Link), e toru ngā take e pā ana ki tēnei – ko te utaina hē o ētahi mōrearea ki runga i te kaiwhakatū, te korenga o ngā kaupapa hei pupuri i tētahi hunga mahi pūkenga, me te korenga o ngā rangatira kaupapa e hiahia ana, e mōhio ana rānei.
I mua ake nei, i whakahē a Derek Firth i ngā whakaritenga kirimana tino kaha ( NZ Herald 30 Mahuru 2018).
Engari, ko ngā kaiwhakahaere me ngā kaiwhakahaere matua o ngā whakahaere hoko, me ngā rōia me ngā kaitohutohu hangarau kāore i te whai wheako e tika ana, ka hē noa iho mā te tūtohu, te tohe rānei i ngā whakaritenga kirimana uaua ka tāpiri koretake ki te wā me te utu. He mea whakamīharo, ko ngā kaitohutohu e mahi ana i tēnei i te wehi kei whakakapia rātou e ngā kaiwhakataetae pakari ake, he tika tonu te āwangawanga nā te mea kāore ā rātou kiritaki i te pūkenga ki te kite i te hapa o ngā huarahi kē atu.
Ki tā mātou titiro, ko te hunga e ngana ana ki te pupuri i te kaimahi kirimana i tētahi mahi, me te kore e kōrero mō tētahi kaupapa nui me ngā mōrearea o te whenua, ngā huringa ture rānei, he mahi hē tēnei, ā, e whakaatu ana i te korenga o te wheako angitu ki ngā kaupapa nui. Engari ko ēnei mahi, ko ēnei nganatanga rānei ki te mahi i ēnei mahi, te āhua nei kua horapa whānuitia i Aotearoa, ā, he maha ngā kaimahi kirimana e tautoko ana i te hononga tahi nā te mea he iti noa ngā ngoikoretanga mō rātou.
Ehara i te mea miharo, he rite tonu te āwangawanga mō ngā para koretake i te United Kingdom, i reira anō i te marama o Hānuere o tēnei tau, i kī ai a Gareth Davies, te tumuaki o te Tari Arotake ā-Motu i reira, kei te maumauria e te United Kingdom ngā tekau piriona pāuna ki ngā kaupapa kāore i te whakahaeretia pai.
He raruraru te mahi tahi. He kōwhiringa hoko tēnei, ko ōna āhuatanga noa ko ngā tikanga whakatau kotahi, te tohatoha i ngā mōrearea me ngā hua katoa o te kaupapa, kia whakaae ai ngā rōpū ki te tikanga wikitoria, hinga rānei, kāore he huarahi ki te whakatau tautohe me te pūnaha kore tautohe/kore whakapae, ā, (ko te tumanako) ka whakakorea ngā tautohe me te tango i te mea pai rawa atu mō ngā mātāpono o te kaupapa. He pai te ahua i roto i te ariā engari ka nui ake te wā me te utu i roto i te mahi.
Te āhua nei kua noho hei momo ahua rongonui i ētahi whenua o Ahitereiria, inā koa ko Wikitōria, ā, whai muri mai ko Waka Kotahi NZTA.
I te tau 2009 i whakaputa te Tari Putea o te Kāwanatanga o te Rohe o Wikitōria i tētahi rangahau mō te mahi tahi i roto i te Rāngai Tūmatanui o Ahitereiria.
Ko te Kitenga Matua 3 ko te hiahia nui o ngā kaiuru ehara i te rangatira (ina koa ko ngā kaimahi kirimana) ki te hono atu i ētahi atu tikanga tuku tuku iho. Ka whakaae puku te nuinga o ngā kaimahi kirimana he whakamārama tino kuware tēnei.
Nā tētahi kaikōrero Peretānia mātau i whakaahua te hononga mahi tahi me te mahi tahi he iti noa iho te wāhi mō ngā kaupapa uaua hangarau e tika ana mō te wā roa, kia taea ai e te tīma kaupapa te piko me te neke haere i roto i ngā huringa ohorere ina hiahiatia he maha ngā āhuatanga me te auahatanga.
E ai ki ngā Aratohu Whakaaetanga Hononga ā-Motu mai i te Tari Hanganga me te Waka o Ahitereiria, ko ngā kaupapa e tika ana mō te kirimana hononga he maha ngā āhuatanga e whai ake nei:
- He mōrearea kei tēnei kaupapa kāore e taea te tautuhi tika, te ine rānei i roto i tētahi take pakihi, i mua atu rānei i te tuku tono.
- He nui rawa te utu mō te whakawhiti mōrearea.
- Me tīmata wawe tonu te kaupapa i mua i te tautuhi katoa i ngā mōrearea, i mua rānei i te whakatau i te whānuitanga o te kaupapa, ā, kia rite hoki te rangatira ki te tango i te mōrearea arumoni o te hua utu iti iho i te pai.
- He nui ngā mōhiotanga, ngā pūkenga, me te kaha o te rangatira ki te awe, ki te whai wāhi atu rānei ki te whakawhanake me te whakatutuki i te kaupapa.
- Mā te huarahi mahi tahi ki te aromatawai me te whakahaere i te mōrearea ka puta he hua pai ake.
E hia ngā kaupapa i Aotearoa kua whakamahia te hononga ā-iwi ka whai i ngā āhuatanga kua whakahuatia ake nei? Ki tā mātou whakaaro, ko te whakaora rū whenua o Canterbury anake pea ka tika. Ahakoa i roto i taua take, i te wā i whakamanahia ai e te Kaiwhakahaere me te Kaitātari Matua ki tō tātou Paremata kei te whakapaua te moni a te iwi i runga i te huarahi whai hua me te whai hua, ā, ko ngā hinonga a te iwi e whai wāhi ana kei te whakahaere i ngā mōrearea o te hanga anō, i kī ia: "I kite ngā hinonga i te hiahia kia arotakehia anō tā rātou tauira hoko i muri i te rū whenua nui tuarua, ā, i whakamahia he tikanga kua whakapumautia hei whiriwhiri i tētahi huarahi e tika ana mō ngā āhuatanga".
E tino ruarua ana mātou mēnā kei roto i taua wāhanga tētahi huarahi nui (ahakoa te rahi), ā, e whakapono ana mātou i taea te whakaiti i te nui o te wā me te utu i Transmission Gully ki te raki o Te Whanganui-a-Tara me te toronga o te huarahi tere ki te raki o Puhoi mā te hoko tuku iho.
I te nuinga o te wā, he maha ngā ngoikoretanga o te hononga tahi, tae atu ki te utu mō te whakatū me te whakahaere hononga tahi, te korenga o te whakawhiti mōrearea, te ngoikore o ngā whakaritenga whakahaere hei huna i te whanaketanga ngoikore o ngā whakaritenga, te whakahaere kaupapa ngoikore me ērā atu mea, te koretake o te wā me te tahua, te whakangawari i ngā uauatanga nā te pūnaha kore tautohe/kore whakapae me te kore he huarahi ki te whakatau tautohe, te hiahia kia kotahi te whakaaro i roto i te whakatau kaupapa he uaua i ētahi wā, ā, i ētahi wā ka whakamahia hei whakatutuki i tētahi painga arumoni huna, ngā take utu mō te moni me ētahi atu. Ko ngā tari kāwanatanga e whai wāhi ana ki te hononga tahi ka mutu ko rātou te utu mō te wāhanga nui o ngā hapa a ngā kaiwhakatū. I roto i te poto, ka taea e te hononga tahi te tāpiri nui ki te utu o tētahi kaupapa, ā, he maha ngā wā kāore he uara mō te kiritaki. Me tino whakapau kaha ngā rōpū katoa ki ngā hononga tahi me te hiahia pono kia pai te mea pai mō te kaupapa mō ia rōpū takitahi. Kua whakaahuatia pai tēnei hei kauhoe tukutahi me ngā mango.
Nā te nui o te whakapaunga wā me te whakapaunga utu, kua hoki whakamuri ngā kaitukumahi nui o Ahitereiria me Aotearoa, me te whakanui i roto i ā rātou kaupapa here hokohoko o nāianei ko te tūnga o te mahi tahi tētahi o ngā tikanga maha e tika ana.
Ina hoki, i ngā wā tata nei, nā te nui, te uaua, me te tere o ngā mahi whakatikatika e hiahiatia ana mō SH25A i Coromandel, i tino angitu a Waka Kotahi ki te whakamahi i te huarahi hokohoko hoahoa-hanga me te whai huatanga o te wā me te utu.
Ehara te hononga ā-iwi me ērā atu momo mahi tahi i te momo kirimana e hiahiatia ana i Āhia, i Ūropi, i te Waenganui Rawhiti, i te USA, i Amerika ki te Tonga, tae atu ki tētahi wāhi iti noa iho i te United Kingdom, ina hoki e whitu ngā momo paerewa hei whakamahi.
Nō nā tata nei a Rabin Rabindran i hoki mai i tana mahi i Singapore mō ngā marama e toru, ā, i miharo ia ki te tere o te whanaketanga o ngā hanganga tae atu ki te hanganga o ngā teihana MRT hou me ngā whare noho tūmatanui. Ko te hoahoa hanga me ētahi atu momo kirimana tuku iho he kaupapa noa iho. Kāore i tino rangona te hononga tahi. Ko ā rātou Tikanga Paerewa o te Kirimana a te Rāngai Tūmatanui, te mea tino noa mō ngā kirimana rāngai tūmatanui, ehara i te kirimana hononga tahi.
He maha, he whānui hoki ngā huarahi kē atu i te mahi tahi, ā, kua pai te whai hua mō ngā kaupapa hanganga puta noa i te ao.
Tuatahi, ko te hanganga tuku iho o te hoahoa a te rangatira. Koinei te momo kirimana o te ao e whakamahia whānuitia ana. He painga tōna, ko te hoahoa anake kei mua i a ia e utu ana te kaiwhakatū, ā, he rerekē ngā huringa. He iti noa te whānuitanga o te utu. Engari kia angitu ai te whakamahinga, me tata oti te hoahoa i mua i te utunga. Koinei te wāhi i maha ai ngā hinganga i Aotearoa. "Ka hinga te pū" a ngā rangatira kaupapa mā te tuku ki te kaiwhakatū i mua i te tino oti o te hoahoa. Kātahi ka kore e taea te aukati i te nui o te wā me te utu.
Tuarua, te hoahoa hanga. Ka taea te whakanui ake i te uara o tēnei huarahi mā te whai wāhi wawe mai o ngā kaimahi kirimana, ā, ka tukuna he tono mō ngā whakataetae. E mōhio ana mātou i whakamahia angitu tēnei mō te hokonga o mua o ngā tereina hiko mō Te Whanganui-a-Tara me Tāmaki Makaurau, me ētahi atu whakaritenga mō te tiaki mō te wā roa.
E mōhio ana mātou i angitu te whakamahinga o te hoahoa hanga e On-Track mō te whakapūmau i te hiko o te whatunga tereina o Tāmaki Makaurau.
Tuatoru, he maha atu anō ngā momo hokohoko pēnei i ngā kirimana Utu Whainga Whakatenatena e tohaina ai e te Tumuaki me te Kaituku he mōrearea me he utu huri noa i te ūnga. He mea rongonui tēnei i NSW; he kirimana utu pumau engari me te tiritiri mōrearea huri noa i ngā āhuatanga motuhake, hei tauira, te pikinga utu.
Ka tere tonu te whakaiti i te ingoa o ēnei huarahi kē atu mēnā ka whakaurua ngā kupu taumaha kāore e hiahiatia ana, e whakatakoto ana i ngā herenga wairangi ki runga i te kaiwhakatū, pērā i ngā mōrearea kāore e taea e ia te whakahaere.
Hei whakamutunga, kāore he wāhi mō te hono kirimana i Aotearoa engari i roto i ngā āhuatanga tino iti kua whakaahuatia. Nā ēnei i hua ake ai he wā me he utu tāpiri kāore e tika ana. Ko ngā momo kirimana tuku iho te mea pai ake, ā, he maha ngā whai wāhitanga hei whakapai ake i aua momo.
E toru ngā tino take mō te whakapaunga utu me te wā ko te tuku i te kirimana ki te kaiwhakatū i mua i te otinga o te hoahoa, te whakamahi i te hononga kirimana ina kore e tika, me te whakauru i ngā tikanga whakakatakata o te kirimana e uta ana ki runga i te kaiwhakatū ngā mōrearea kāore nei e taea e ia te whakahaere.
