Papamuri
I te 25 o Hūrae 2016, i uru atu a Gemcan Constructions Pty Ltd ( Gemcan ) me te Kura Tuarua o Westbourne ( WGS ) ki tētahi kirimana hanga mō ngā mahi maha i tētahi puni o WGS. I puta he tautohe mō te mahi me ngā utu, ā, mō tēnei i rapua e ngā rōpū he whakataunga i raro i te Ture SOP. I tono a WSG kia arotakehia te whakataunga e te ture.
Arotakenga ā-ture (2017)
I tono a WGS kia arotakehia te whakataunga utu i roto i te Kōti Matua o Wikitōria, ā, i angitu ki te whakakore. I whakatau a Tā Robson J kua hē te kaiwhakawā i tana kitenga he kore mana te pānui a WGS e kī ana ka tangohia ngā mahi e toe ana kia mahia i raro i te Kirimana mai i ngā ringaringa o Gemcan (te pānui tango) nā te mea kāore i tukuna tika ki te Kaihanga.
Me whakatau tātou i te take? (2020)
Haunga ngā tautohe utu, kāore i taea e ngā rōpū te whakaae he wāhanga whakatau tautohe tika tā rātou. I whai a Gemcan kia tukuna ngā tautohe ki te whakatau tautohe i raro i te wāhanga e tika ana o te kirimana. I whakahē a WGS i tēnei, me te tautohe kāore te kirimana i te hanga i tētahi whakaaetanga here ki te whakatau tautohe nā te mea kāore i roto ngā taipitopito mō te whakatūnga o te kaiwhakatau tautohe me ngā ture whakatau tautohe ka pā.
I te whakatau i tēnei take hei tautoko i a Gemcan, i kitea e te Kōti kei roto i te kirimana he whakaaetanga whakatau tautohe whai mana e āhei ai te Kōti ki te whakatau i te whakatūnga o tētahi kaiwhakatau tautohe i raro i te wāhanga 11 o te CAA. Kātahi ka tīmata a Gemcan i ngā tukanga whakatau tautohe ki a WGS.
Te Whakataunga (2021)
I te whakatau tautohe, i whiwhi a Gemcan i tētahi whakataunga hei tautoko i a ia mō te kereme utu i raro i te Ture SOP. Ko tētahi o ngā tautohe i whakaarahia e Gemcan ko te kore whai mana o te pānui tango-atu i runga i te whakaaro kāore a Gemcan i takahi nui i te kirimana. I tautohe a WGS i aukatia a Gemcan ki te whakaputa i taua tautohe ("kua whakakorea") nā te mea kua whakatauhia kētia te mana o te pānui tango-atu e Robson J i roto i te tukanga arotake ture.
I kitea e te kaiwhakatau ko te whakataunga a Robson J i herea ki te whakaaro mēnā i hē te kaiwhakatau i tana whakatau kua tukuna tika te pānui tango-atu. Kāore i aukatia a Gemcan i te tautohe i roto i te whakatau tautohe he kore mana te pānui i runga i te whakaaro kāore i takahi i te kirimana. Ko te mutunga iho o tēnei he kore mana te pānui tango-atu i te kaupapa, ā, nō reira, kāore a WGS i tango tika i te mahi mai i a Gemcan.
Te Kōti Matua (2022)
Kātahi ka tono a Gemcan kia whakamanahia te whakataunga whakatau tautohe, ā, ka tono a WGS kia whakakorehia te whakataunga i runga i te whakaaro he taupatupatu ki ngā kaupapa here a te iwi. I tautohe a WGS i "āraia" te kaiwhakatau tautohe i te kitenga kāore a Gemcan i takahi i te kirimana. I tautohe a WGS i whai mana ngā mātāpono o te res judicata me te issue estoppel.
Ko te tikanga o te res judicata kua whakatauhia tētahi mea e tētahi kōti whai mana, nō reira kāore e taea te whai atu anō e ngā rōpū kotahi. Mā te take estoppel ka ārai i tētahi rōpū e ngana ana ki te tautohe anō i tētahi take meka, ture rānei kua whakatauhia i mua i roto i ngā whakahaerenga ture. E tautohe ana hoki a WGS kua whakamahia he Anshun estoppel. Ko tēnei momo estoppel he momo take estoppel e mahi ana hei ārai i tētahi rōpū ki te kawe kereme i roto i ngā whakahaerenga i tika kia kawea (engari kāore i kawea) i roto i ngā whakahaerenga o mua.
Ko ngā take matua e rua ko:
- mēnā he raruraru i puta mai i te aukati (i te aukati Anshun rānei); ā,
- Mena koinā te āhua, me whakakore rānei te whakataunga whakatau tautohe nā te mea nā te korenga o te kaiwhakatau tautohe ki te whakamahi i te take estoppel, estoppel rānei a Anshun i takahi i te kaupapa here a te iwi whānui.
I whakatau a Kaiwhakawā Riordan ko te take i whakaarohia i roto i te keehi arotake whakawa ko te kore mana o te panui tango-atu nā te mea i tukuna i muri i te tangohanga o te mahi a te WGS mai i a Gemcan. Ko te whakatau a Robson J i hē te kaiwhakawā ki te kite he kore mana te panui tango-atu i mahia i runga i ngā whakaritenga tukanga mō te tuku i te panui tango-atu. Kāore a Robson J i whakatau mō te ihirangi matua o te panui tango-atu – arā, mehemea i takahi a Gemcan i te kirimana. I roto i ēnei āhuatanga, i kitea e Kaiwhakawā Riordan kāore he take aukati i aukati i te kaiwhakawa ki te whakatau kāore a Gemcan i takahi nui i te kirimana, ā, nō reira he kore mana te Panui Tango-atu.
I kitea anō hoki e te Kaiwhakawā Riordan kāore i puta he aukati a Anshun nā te mea kāore a Gemcan i kī i mua i a Kaiwhakawā Robson (i roto i te tukanga arotake whakawa) kāore he takahi nui o te kirimana e tika ana kia tukuna e te WGS te pānui tango-atu he mea koretake. Ki te kitea he rerekētanga, he mea whakahē ki ngā whāinga o te Ture SOP, i hangaia hei whakarite i te utu tere me te rere o te moni mā te tukanga whakatau tere, me te whakatau whakamutunga i ngā tautohe i muri mai. Mā te tono i ngā rōpū ki te whakaara ake i ngā take uaua i te wā whakatau, i te arotake whakawa rānei o te whakataunga whakatau ka hinga te kaupapa o te kaupapa ture.
Ahakoa i kitea kāore he aukati i puta, i whai whakaaro tonu a Riordan J mēnā ka taupatupatu te whakataunga a te kaiwhakatau tautohe ki te kaupapa here a te iwi whānui nā te hapa a te kaiwhakatau tautohe.
I kī ia me whakawhāiti te whakamārama i te rerekētanga kaupapa here tūmatanui. I tana whakahua i tēnei, me te whai whakaaro ki te huarahi o te wawaotanga iti rawa i roto i ngā tukanga whakatau tautohe kua whakatōkia ki roto i te CAA, i kitea e Riordan J ko te korenga o te kaiwhakatau tautohe ki te whakamahi i tētahi aukati take ka taea te whakauru atu ki te kaupapa here tūmatanui. ENGARI kāore taua kaupapa e whai mana mēnā kāore he hē tūturu, he koretake rānei i roto i te whakatau.
I whakatau te Kaitohutohu ahakoa i kitea e ia he hē te kaiwhakawa, kāore i kitea he hē tūturu, he whanoke rānei.
Whakamutunga
Ko te arotahi me aro ki ngā mea i whakatauhia i roto i te whakataunga o mua. Mā tēnā ka whakatau te nui, te iti rānei o ngā mea e toe ana hei whakaaroaro mā te kaiwhakawā o muri mai…Me whakahaere tetahi tātaritanga o ngā āhuatanga ōrite me te whakaaro ki te tukanga pakari me te poto o te wā mō ngā whakataunga. Ki te kore e mārama kua oti katoa te whakatau i ngā take o te kereme, kua tika rānei kia whakahaerea i roto i te whakataunga o mua, me tūpato tēnei Kōti kei pokanoa ki te whakataunga a te kaiwhakawā. Kaua e whakahaere i tētahi tātaritanga pai o ngā take i whakaarahia i roto i te whakataunga o mua. Ko te kaiwhakawā, ehara i tēnei Kōti, te mea kei te tūranga pai ki te whakahaere i taua tātaritanga me te tae atu ki tētahi whakataunga i runga i ngā mōhiohio i tukuna ki tōna aroaro me ngā tuku a ngā rōpū.
